Slimelite BBS

Timber!

Back to HAM

From Stuart Presnell · 1996-04-07 02:33 · #65462 in HAM

Hello Paul!

24 Mar 96 19:58, Paul Gardner wrote to Stuart Presnell:

 PG>> BTW am I the only one to think Tuvok makes a terrible
 PG>> Vulcan? He's so wooden, I'm surprised the Voyager crew don't
 PG>> get splinters when they touch him.
 SP>> Not that I disagree, but Tuvok is how a Vulcan is supposed to be,

 PG> I guess so, but couldn't they come up with just one interesting aspect?

I'm sure they'll think of something eventually.  Maybe he has a few skeletons in his closet?

 PG>> I'm not averse to the principle of a black Vulcan officer, I
 PG>> just think the implementation is disastrous in this case.
 SP>> His race is wholly irrelevant - it's his personality that counts.

 PG> I know, but others have made such a big deal of Tuvok being a
 PG> black Vulcan that I didn't want people to think that this was the
 PG> reason that I wasn't keen on him.

And as I pointed out, we object to him because he is dull, not because of any racial issues.  We are agreed.

 PG> Let's be absolutely clear - the only thing I have against the actor who
 PG> plays Tuvok is that he's so incredibly wooden.

Agreed.  I would suggest that Kim is similarly timberish, and Paris too.  In
fact, most of the characters are either very poorly developed or (even worse) highly annoying.  They /must/ make Chakotay into a good commander (which he already shows signs of, see "Persistance of Vision"), and give Kes some fire to balance the weakness of her personality.  As for Janeway, Tuvok, Paris and Kim, I would assign them all to airlock inspection duty! ;)

SmP


--- GEcho 1.00
 * Origin: SmP's Point off Pacific Lightning BBS (2:440/7.46)