Slimelite BBS

Times Arrow

Back to HAM

From Paul Johnston · 1996-04-05 02:48 · #65427 in HAM

Hello Matthew.

 MP>  1) The crew investigate the alien planet and get thrown back in time
 MP> because Data's head was found. Now how his head get there in the first
 MP> place? Bit of a catch 22.

Have you seen the Voyager episode Parralax? In it, Voyager goes to rescue a ship from a temporal anomaly, and it turns out that the ship is themselves in the future or something (it's been a while :-) Anyway, Paris says this and Janeway replies something along the lines of "one of the harder elements to grasp in temporal mechanics is that effect can precede cause." I personally think that the paradox is all part of the fun.

 MP>  2) What would happen to Guinan,

Well, possibly the same as above.

 MP> I assume she would have seeked the job on the Enterprise because of
 MP> her meeting with Picard in the past

Yes, I recall that that was the case (from her conversation with Picard in 10 forward).

 MP> Now if Guinan didn't join the Enterprise then look how different
 MP> things would have turned out, Yesterday's Enterprise for example.

I haven't seen that (only been interested about a year), but there'd probably be no more Crusher after Suspisions, and thinking about it, Picard wouldn't be on the away team, so who'd send the message through data? The Enterprise would have fired without phase modulating (or whatever) their phasers (or was it proton torpedos) so they would have destoryed the universe or something nasty like that.

 MP>  3) Riker seemed bothered about destroying the cave and so trapping
 MP> Picard in the past. Has he forgotten about Time Warps and the Guardian
 MP> of Forever? He could nip back to the past pick up Picard and go back.

I don't think he would be allowed to mess about with time just to get Picard. Picard would probably have no choice but to phaser himself to prevent him screwing up Earth's timeline.

Paul

--- FMail 1.0g
 * Origin: Paul's region of zero area in the plane, Manchester, (2:250/109.38)