From John Kennedy · 1996-03-31 18:08 · #65253 in MTG_UK
In a message of 28 Mar 96 Damien Guard wrote to me:
-=>> Quoting John Kennedy to Dave Rosendale <=-
{Fido vs Internet }
I don't really want to keep this going, as there is nothing
to gain from a Fido vs internet debate. However, I would
disagree with some of your the benefits of Fido over the Net
very strongly and would not like them to go unchallenged in
this public echo.
DG> But on a BBS you also have the advantage of:
DG> All new files listed in a keystroke
Many Internet sites do this. Ok, with a single click then.
Try www.jumbo.com for example.
DG> BBS never slows down as much as an Internet site
You can be accessing many sites at once, up to bandwidth of
the feed into your ISP, or from your ISP to your computer
via your modem. Sure, you won't beat a straight 28K Zmodem
link unless you have a T1 line or at least ISDN, but Fido
will not let you take part in IRC whilst download mail and
FTPing software.
DG> ANSI screens are much quicker
Quicker than what? A text based FTP client? No. A web page
-- yes: however, if Web pages were based on low resolution
colour with 16 shades they would be faster too. That
argument makes no sense...
DG> Message content is much better quality than Usenet
Now that is debatable. With over 14,000 Usenet threads you
do find some gems. The input is more global and a lot of
professionals make use of it: as one example, you won't find
people from Amiga Techologies writing in the Amiga_UK echo.
DG> File transfers at the highest speed you can handle
See above.
DG> Much easier to search thru file base
Not true... if you use the right Web sites. I've used many
BBSs where downloading software is incredibly difficult and
convoluted. Using a good Web site is a lot easier.
DG> Can e-mail the sysop for help
Um.. now that depends on the Sysop, doesn't it? Another
message in this very echo seems to disprove that.
Now, please. This echo isn't the place for Fido/Internet.
They both have their strengths and weaknesses, and they both
are very useful.
johnk
--- Spot 1.3a #741
* Origin: IT - The "&C" is still inside the magazine. (2:443/13.4)