From Alex Macphee · 1996-04-12 05:00 · #64148 in INVENTIONS
Hello Tim, [Tim Parsons to Alex Macphee, Mar 30 '96] TP>> he's not going to go the distance with *her*, in terms of his commitment TP>> to their relationship, then he deserves all he gets, in my view. AM> I'm not sure I understand this, since it seems to imply that AM> abortion has a punishment value in some cases. TP> Not my implication, but yours. I am inferring rather than implying. What, exactly, then, does he "deserve", in the context of a discussion of the father's lost rights over his unborn child? TP> I'm still not convinced of the putative TP> agony suffered by the male partner in the situations we're debating. I think it comparable to that of a mother losing her child. Fathers are not different beings with different feelings over their children. Women do not have the monopoly on parental suffering. TP> I don't have a problem with the alleged consequences suffered by him. With respect, his problem is painful independently of how you may perceive it. Decoupling him from his feelings by the tactical insertion of an "alleged" is itself a kind of dehumanisation of another man's deepest feelings. TP> No; it says that if he can't be sufficiently committed to his partner to TP> support her in a decision that will affect her whole life, then the TP> level of commitment that will be required of him to support a child his TP> partner didn't want is unlikely to be sufficient to the task. This is a complete non sequitur. He is the one demonstrating commitment, she is not. Commitment is most often shown in the face of adversity, not in faint-hearted compliance with what you feel to be fundamentally wrong in the first place. TP> Her first loyalty is to herself, inasmuch as she must protect her TP> ability to bear children later. For sure, some loyalty to her partner TP> can't hurt, but if his eye is fixed on the short term with no view to TP> potentially damaging consequences, We both accept that rearing a child is a long term commitment. Yet here you now argue that in wishing to ensure the survival of his child, his eye is only "fixed on the short term"! TP> Arguably, she may be TP> committing herself to children later with the same partner if he TP> supports her now; this strengthens his genetic survival and may TP> demonstrate greater loyalty than you suggest. Recall that I am confining my attention to the case of proposed abortion where there is no identified reason due to medical risk to child or mother. It is thus even more arguable that his genetic survival is jeopardised by a partner who will abort his child under such circumstances. AM> Does not abortion AM> disenfranchise the real victim of the process? TP> "Victim" implies both hurt and the ability to perceive it. It certainly does not. One might just as easily dismiss a murder as a 'victimless crime' if the putative victim had been slipped a drug in his cocoa that caused him to die painlessly and unwittingly in his sleep, for he would perceive nothing at all of what had happened to him and suffer no hurt. TP> and if we can be sure that no hurt occurs, then there is no TP> "victim" and there is no person to disenfranchise. Don't forget to stick some litmus paper into your cocoa tonight! <g> TP> ... Oxymoron: Plastic glasses. Plastic rubber, curiously enough, isn't an oxymoron. <g> -Alex --- MsgPost 1.1 * Origin: Voyager (01483 751324) (2:440/31)