From Tim Parsons · 1996-04-09 23:44 · #63935 in INVENTIONS
In reply to Crumbly Candy Bars! by Dave Langridge
Hi Manny,
With one bound, Manny was by her side. Norah felt his hot breath
on her cheek as he ripped the thin silk from Re: Crumbly Candy Bars!
MN> My argument is that what we can regard as "human", or even
MN> "fully human", is a purely arbitrary decision based on the
MN> definition of "human" we decide to accept. It therefore seems
MN> clear to me that the ethical issue of abortion remains the same
MN> whether or not the particular definition of "human" we accept
MN> includes the unborn.
I understand what you're getting at now; thanks.
The problem, I suspect, is that trying to remove the
MN> 1. Foetuses become human when they can experience pain
(or similar) premise from the chain is practically impossible; it
requires that people accept that
MN> 1. It is wrong to abort a creature capable of feeling pain
is an appropriate premise to apply to humans, given that we are trained
to believe that we stand apart (by virtue of our intelligence, or our
creation by some god or other, or simply our arrogance) from the rest of
the animal kingdom that will be assumed to be what is implied by the
word "creature".
Especially since one may expect the word "abort" to be replaced by the
word "kill" in fairly short order. We suddenly have a framework for
vegetarianism (which you may not see as a problem, but I remain firmly
convinced that if we were designed omnivorous, it's likely to be in our
best interests to stay that way - at least until we evolve an extra
stomach or three).
MN> Your characterisation of the possible effect of introducing
MN> religious premises into argument as being like division by zero
MN> is quite superb.
High praise indeed; thanks!
MN> This opens another interesting debate. Do you think killing is
MN> wrong under all circumstances?
No. But I think it's wrong *most* of the time, and I have serious
problems with - for instance - the use of weapons designed to kill by
policemen whose first duty is not to punish (which, it seems to me, they
take upon themselves more and more) but to apprehend criminals ("alleged
criminals", if you want to be pedantic).
MN> I suppose this raises two questions. Firstly, is his first duty
MN> to the mother? And secondly, even if it is, is it his duty to
MN> keep her alive, or ensure that her wishes are respected without
MN> pressure or interference?
Yes to the first, and her life (and its preservation in particular)
*must* take precedence over her wishes every time.
This is where (to skip ahead slightly) the concept of euthanasia needs
the most careful thought. If every person who went to their doctor
demanding to be killed to take them out of their misery, we might solve
the problem of clinical depression overnight, but this is clearly not an
acceptable solution. I'm inclined to err on the side of caution and
suggest that while euthanasia should *not* be unavailable, its
invocation should be as far from routine as it's possible to make it;
even requiring the say-so of the Courts, perhaps, before it can be
administered.
MN> I would also
MN> take issue with the word "force"; surely he can be heard
MN> without being thought of as "forcing". There is a vital
MN> distinction between persuasion and compulsion.
I'm not suggesting that he should not be allowed to attempt to persuade
his partner to change her views. But I *am* suggesting that he should
not have the _right_ to make her bear the child if persuasion fails and,
further, that if that right existed and were invoked, it could only be
for reasons that were fundamentally selfish (which I'm prepared to argue
religious grounds also would be, in this case, but not now...)
MN> There are
MN> three interests to be taken into account.
Aha; are there? Throughout? At what point does the foetus acquire an
"interest"?
MN> In practice, if asked to
MN> vote I would, in fact, vote in favour of pregnancy on demand,
I assume you missed the phrase "termination of" out here... ;-)
MN> But this
MN> is just an instinctive view: I cannot yet support it rationally
MN> to my own satisaction.
I suspect you will; your instincts (when they support mine, of course!)
are generally pretty sound, I'd say... :-)
Best regards,
Tim
... Do you think a baker would hire a loafer?
--- Via Silver Xpress V4.3 UK-01241
---
* Origin: Cambridge Classic (Mail Only) (2:2504/109)