Slimelite BBS

Crumbly Candy Bars!

Back to INVENTIONS

From Ben Lovejoy · 1996-04-09 00:49 · #63900 in INVENTIONS

Mark :>

[Quoting you to Manny Neira] 

  MS> Could you answer another question for me? Is there a difference
  MS> between doing a killing and allowing a killing to be done?

How are we defining 'allowing'?

A gunman points a gun at a child and says he's going to pull the trigger. Nothing we say dissuades him. We have a gun and fail to shoot him. He kills the child.

A man leaves a pub after we've witnessed him drink two double-whiskies. He gets into his car and drives off. We fail to call the police to report him. Ten miles down the road, he hits and kills a cyclist.

You're walking down the road and notice a loose slate on the roof of a house. You fail to alert the householder. A fortnight later, the slate falls from the roof and kills the postman.

You watch a TV report about people dying in a distant country for lack of oral rehydration therapy sachets. You fail to take any action. They continue to die.

Which of the above amount to allowing someone to die? Which are morally equivalent to killing?

Ben

--- MacWoof Regd:16May92
 * Origin: ben@trc-london.com | www.trc-london.com/trc/ (2:254/4.1)