Slimelite BBS

Re: United vs City

Back to INVENTIONS

From Lindsay Macphee · 1996-04-08 06:30 · #63838 in INVENTIONS

In reply to United vs City by Denis McMahon

Hello Louise,

[Louise West to Lindsay Macphee]

LW> Hiya Lindsay! On 24-Mar-96 you were chatting about United vs
LW> City, so I thought I'd reply:

Gosh yeah did you see the derby on Sat? Ryan Giggs' goal was terrific!!

LW> In England yes.

No.

LM> I take it by your Ireland statement you are refering to the Eire vs
LM> England match at Lansdowne Road.
LM> There were no deaths. A lot of injuries yes, but nobody died.
LW> But a lot of people could have died.

That however is not what you said and nor is it the point.

LM> And the hooliganism at that game was due to poor police control.
LW> WRONG! It was due to large amounts of football fans, found
LW> to be belonging to racist gangs, who were looking for a
LW> fight.

Without wishing to be rude, did you actually *listen* to the news then or did you just *hear* it? It was widely known by the FA, the Travel Club AND the police that these thugs were intent on going. These three organisations also gave lists of these people to the Garda whose responsability it was to police the game. They failed big time. Therefore it was poor police control.

LM> Hillsborough disaster = poor police control.
LW> I'll agree on that one. The only reason there was a disaster
LW> at hillsborough was because they allowed a lot of late fans
LW> into the stand, more than there was room for.

The reason was also poor police communication. The officer who gave the command to open the gates did so because there was people being crushed OUTSIDE the ground. There should have been measurements taken to have kept the fans without tickets away from the ground. The fans weren't just late, most of them had no tickets. It was also said before the game that a lot of fans were likely to turn up on spec AND there were also doubts raised on Hillsborough as a venue because of its size.

LM>  As an avid football fan I can only recall one death even remotly
LM> related to football and that was last year just before the FA Cup sem
LM> final between Crystal Palace and Manchester United.
LW> There are probably a lot more deaths connected to football
LW> than that lone death.

Maybe so but nowhere like the amount you suggest. There really are more deaths in religion than in football.

LW>  Shall I write something controversial?

Go on then.

LW> Okay. The Docklands
LW> and West End bombings, what were the motives? To kill people
LW> who belong to the religion the bombers disliked?

Those bombings were by the IRA. The IRA's campain is essentially religious. It is now very political but it is still a religious war.

LW> I very much doubt there were prodestants or even groups of catholics
LW> living in Docklands.

Would you like to bet on that? I would bet everything I have that you are wrong on that one! The way you say that suggests to me that you believe that those are minority religions in this country. We both know that is false. Are you really trying to say that none of the people that live in the docklands or in the west end go to church?

LM> the war in The Former Yugoslavia was a religious war, the war over the
LM> Gaza Strip is a religious war. I don't even have to mention figures
LM> but they run into MILLIONS.
LW> Okay, I'm sorry if I didn't mention it, but when I wrote
LW> 'there are more deaths in football' I was thinking of
LW> England/UK, not the rest of the world. 

Hey, come on Louise, you can't cop out like that. If you only meant UK you should have said that in the begining.

LM>  Do you still think that:-
LW>> In football there are more deaths than religion.
LW> In England, yes. The world, no.

Do you include Eire and NI in that? Cos if that's the case then you are still wrong.

LW>  I'll start another subject do you think there are more
LW> deaths due to drugs or religion? .

Ha! Before I get involved in this one, do you mean UK or World?? :') And can we include the IRA?

 luv
 Lin.
--- timEd-B11
 * Origin:  Voyager, +44-1483-751324   (2:440/31)