Slimelite BBS

Babylon 5, a recommendation...

Back to INVENTIONS

From Graham Marsden · 1996-04-06 23:26 · #63763 in INVENTIONS

Hi Ian,

[Re: Babylon 5]

 GM> Don't make the mistake of expecting it to be "just another SF series"
 GM> or expecting it to be like Star Trek because it *isn't*.

IB>  Yeah, I mean in Bab.5, there are aliens on a "ship" run by humans,
IB> working for everlasting peace throughout the universe......

IB>  ...... umm.. yeah. ;))

Excuse me if I don't get involved in this one again, but I've just been
through this argument twice with Mark Stevens and David Otton in the Babylon
5 and F&SF echoes in *major* detail.

I will merely point out that there is a *LOT* more to B5 than that, and it
is only on the *most superficial* level that it can be compared to Trek.

B5 has *depth*, it has continuity of plots, it has characters and enemies
who are not two dimensional cardboard cutouts, it has traitors and
backstabbing and double dealing and *much* more.

What does Trek have? Moral messages...

 GM> give the series time and I think you will begin to appreciate that this
 GM> series is setting a new standard for television Science Fiction.

IB>  How much did they pay you for that?! ;)

Absolutely nothing. If you take a look into the F&SF echo you will see that
I am not afraid to criticise bad writing/ tv etc and I certainly *don't*
recommend anything that isn't well above the standard.

Cheers,
Graham.

--- GEcho/32 1.20/Pro
 * Origin: METRIC BBS * 01705 871471 * Multi Line * V34 28k8 * (2:251/21)