From Dave Langridge · 1996-04-04 13:46 · #63668 in INVENTIONS
following up a message from Ben Lovejoy to Graham Marsden:
BL> Does anyone in here have about three weeks' worth of CR archives in
BL> a format which can be free-text searched? I don't recall the
That is wot he asked.....
***********************
Area : Non Computer Chat
Date : Tue Mar 12, 13:54 scn
From : Ben Lovejoy 2:254/4.1
To : Graham Marsden
Subj : Margins
+------------------------------------------------------------------------------ [Graham used netmail for a reply to a message in here as he didn't want to
reveal his margins on his starter-pack. I've thus pasted an edited copy of my
reply in here.]
Graham :>
GM> This *still*
GM> lets me undercut the other companies *AND* I make a tidyprofit.
That sounds fine, though you're only counting your direct costs. Ok, you don't
have any overheads to speak of, but you need to cost in both your own minimum
income, plus advertising and promotional costs.
Let's say you need to earn L6k/year personal income after tax. Tax is very low
at that level since your personal allowance is well over half that sum and
you'll start out on 20% tax and then move onto 25%, so let's call it L7k before
tax. (If only tax stayed at that margin ...) All expenses are tax-deductible, so
we can simply add these to the gross income needed - ie. you won't be taxed on
the money needed to cover your business expenses.
Let's say that you do a basic level of advertising and direct mail, etc, costing
L2k/year. That's L9k. And let's allow just L1k for all other incidentals, thus
you need to gross L10k/year. Which is what you estimated yourself.
Now, let's say that your L2k promotional budget buys you one small display ad a
month in Skin 2. If you are significantly undercutting the competition, your ad
doesn't need to be large. And let's say you can also mailshot 1000 people a year
with a simple letter inviting them to take up your L5 catalogue+cuffs deal.
We now need to look at what level of businesss this might realistically
generate.
I have no idea about response levels in this market, they may be better or worse
than average, but let's take some typical rates of 0.5% for a well-targetted ad
in a specialist publication and 1.5% for a *good* mailing-list. Again, I don't
know the circulation of Skin 2, so please correct my figures, but for the moment
I'll say 10,000. This means that over a year you are reaching 120,000 people
(most of them the same, but the response rate is an overall one, so that's
fine). So, you get 0.5% of 120,000 = 600 sales. And from the mailshots you get
1.5% of 1000 = 15 sales. A total of 615 sales.
Your gross margin on the starter deal is <gross margin>, so your total income as
above (L10k) has to be met from this margin. Ok, 615 sales x <gross margin> =
total margin of <total margin>. Whoops. Shortfall of <shortfall = a large sum>.
Divide this by the 615 sales and you are making a loss of <loss/item = a sum
much larger than the price of the pack> per starter-pack.
Now, that's not to say the idea isn't viable, as the starter-deal is intended as
just that. You hope that further sales will result, now that they have your
catalogue. But you can't /rely/ on that. Loss-leaders are a very risky endeavour
if they really do lose you money, as yours does.
One of my own company's activities is producing pages on the world wide web. We
have a 'loss-leader' deal of a single page online for a year for L95. It is
intended to do the same job as your starter-deal - encourage people to buy more
later.
If lots of people took up that offer, and didn't later decide to expand the
site, we wouldn't make a penny on the deal since that figure exactly covers our
total costs. But, importantly, neither would we make a loss. Even if we did
nothing but those deals, we'd still cover our overheads - just!
I'd say you need to rethink your starter-deal somewhat. Or do as I and others
are suggesting, and get a job, running the business evenings and weekends. The
job covers your income needs, so the business only needs to covers its own
direct costs. Then you /can/ afford to do a very cheap starter deal, since you
only need it to cover materials, P&P and promotional costs, provided you
recognise that it will not continue to be viable once you give up the job.
Ben
*******************************
That is wot he wrote :)
Dave L.
--- GEcho 1.20/Pro
* Origin: Home At Last! in the Pleiades Cluster (2:252/820)