Weighing up the Basics Ever since the advent of home computing way back in the early eighties, Ba sic has been the major programming language for the masses. The only real lan guage taught around the world in schools and the only language generally available on all formats from the VAX to the VIC. The questions have always been: 'What book should I buy? What Basic should I use?' and others. If your like me then you might have been discouraged from using Basic by being forced to study it from stuffy old 70's textbooks, handing in assignments regularly and 'DON'T FORGET YOUR REM STATEMENTS!' Ah.. The nostalgia of it all. Much to my initial chargrin there has been a resurgence in the popularity of basic of late with a good many new offerings and old offerings at budget prices and even quite reasonable PD attempts. Ever since Amiga Basic was bundled with the original A500s people have been tinkering whether or not they take programming seriously. Fortunately Amiga Basic doesn't work on the new machines so we shant be embarrased by it anymore. Recently, however, everybody that failed to be impressed by Commodore's offering might have glanced once again at the Volkswagen of computerlanguages. Basic has moved a long way from the old sort built into machines like the C64 and BBC etc. with the most notable change being the dreaded line numbers and useage of new structured loops like do-loop until, functions, procedures and many many others. Of course the question on many users mind is how well they interface to the Amigas graphics and sound capabilities. The fact that commercial games have been written in Blitz and Amos (a modified basic) should be testament enough to there prowess but just how does it shape up to the traditional assembly technique and the popular 'C'. The answer to this revolves around how much you want to pro gram in basic and how much effort as a whole you are prepared to put in. There is no question that if you want to program simultaneous vector balls in 15 zillion colours with real time fractal noise rasterised copper lists then pure assembly is still the only way to go but just how much of the market is that. The new basics are impressive as for the first time they can call the Amigas operating system properly so we could, in theory, create that huge application complete with windows and cycle gadgets and font requesters with very little development time. In my search for the basic that would suit me I tried three basics quite intensively over a period of several months and came out much more enlightened. However, your needs may be different and there are many more Basics about that I haven't had a chance to look at. I decided that I would check out the offerings from PD to the most expensive commercial. The PD offering was FES Basic a new shareware (£10) interpreter offering from Stephen Foley. A cheap but slightly aging GFA basic interpreter which is available for around £10 mail order and which has a compiler available if you decide you need it. Finally the awesome Blitz Basic II compiler from New Zealand's Acid Software group which weighs in at a heavy £50 or so. First a word about the difference between an interpreter and a compiler. An interpreter decodes you program line by line and executes it which makes for rather slow execution for processor intensive operations. Once again it depends on what you consider slow. FES and GFA basic execute at machine code speed compared with Amiga Basic! If speed is your main concern then Blitz Basic certainly has plenty of that on offer with my test of animating a back drop in assembly and in Blitz I couldn't spot any difference in speed! The problem is that Blitz needs to re-compile your program every time you make a slight change where as the interpreted Basics allow modifications in virtually no time at all. Blitz needs you to think about what a change is going to do before you compile it as lengthy programs can take a little while to compile. Blitz is the fastest basic compiler I have ever seen in the compile time stakes but not having an interpreter still slows down the development cycle somewhat. Now a word about the section of the basic packages that you will spend most of your time in. The editor. All programming languages obviously need a front end that enables you to type in you programs and Basic is no exception. All of the Basics I looked at came with their own editor that also ran the interpreter/compiler from a menu of some kind. All preformed basic syntax checking upon hitting return on each line. FesBasic and GFA Basic also preformed auto indentation within loops, subrou tines, conditions and the like. Blitz didn't which is strange as the supplied examples were indented but I came to the conclusion that the author entered them manually. Blitz also missed a lot of potential syntax errors mistaking them for macros or sub routines. This would be a problem for a relatively inexperienced coder. FesBasic and Blitz being the newer of the lot fully support the Workbench look and feel menus and requesters with GFA's being something of a bodge up with simple things like block marking and insertions using those pointless words written on the keypad that you've been wondering about like Home and Pg Up. These are PC emulation functions and hardly ever used on the Amiga. A possible plus for GFA Basic is that it also exists for the PC so porting code and programming on either platform after the initial learning curve would be a cinch, in theory, but I've never seen the PC version. Surprisingly FESBasic came out ahead in the editor stakes which is a shame as the interpreter lets the whole package down. To sum the packages up briefly in cost order: FESBasic: Plus side. PD so cost virtually zero but £10 registered version needed as freely distributable version can't handle anything other than integers (whole num bers). Editor is excellent with faultless intelligent indentation. Support for AGA chip sets and easy to learn graphic commands. Very simple and easy to learn especially using the on line help which gives syntax for every command available from the edi tor all but doing away with the need for a manual! Very nippy for an interpreter in fact the author claims it's even faster that one commercial compiler. Down side. Buggy, buggy, buggy! Even the excellent editor occasionally crashes and certain things like leaving labels on their own line crashes the machine. Recoverable alerts but still a nuisance. Lacks heavy weight features like matrix manipulation and more complex graphics functions. Overall it feels like it's almost there but when the necessary regis tered version costs as much as GFA Basic I can't see many people taking the plunge. Such a shame as the author has put so much time and effort into FES but is reluctant to put more in due to the disappointing response he received for registra tion etc. Future doesn't look good I'm afraid GFA Basic: Plus side. Bargain basement from mail order companies. Established user base. Sturdy heavyweight manual. Fully conversant with the operating system. Compiler available. Comes with plenty of examples of source code. Very full imple mentation of the newer structured Basic with oodles of features I haven't even begun to delve into. Excellent graphic handling and very fast development cycle. Down side. No AGA support. No reason why not due to the open ended nature of the graphics handling commands but I've tried it and zilch! Slowest of the three basics making the compiler an essential buy for serious games programming etc. Strange editor interface with silly PC style control commands. Direct mode doesn't work prop erly as quitting doesn't free all memory and screens making a reset necessary. Di rect mode does strange things. Blitz Basic: Plus side. Fully AGA supportive. Mind blowing speed (forget AMOS). Graphics commands first rate. Closer to the hardware than all other Amiga program ming packages. Absolutely no reason why full commercial games can't be written in Blitz and indeed they have been! Skid Marks is one example. Run time debugger and compiler activated from very good editor. Impressive to say the least. Down Side. Crap manual! Very hard to get to grips with. Not really a proper imple mentation of Basic. Development cycle is fairly long needing re-compiling every time a change is made. Mail order shops stock at over £50 so a bit expensive for your Ba sic experimenter. Conclusion: This ended up being easier than I thought with one Basic letting down the show, proving to be unreliable for general use. FES Basic just doesn't cut the cake but may still be worth a bash if you want to do some quick and dirty things us ing the AGA chip set. Once again it comes down to what you want to do. If your dead set serious about developing commercial quality application software that runs at break neck speed or want to program that game you've been thinking about then Blitz is the way to go. If you want to tinker and knock up programs to log your video collection, keep track of your finances and fancy grabbing a book or two on Basic from the local library then GFA Basic is the way to go. What can you get for £10 these days?!? Then again if you want the best of both worlds then buy both. They are sufficiently different to warrant the extra tenner for GFA. Happy coding.